Thursday, February 26, 2009

Kara DioGuardi is ruining American Idol!



I told you several weeks ago when American Idol first began its eighth season that I was disappointed in it. I believe I may have even said I wasn’t going to watch it. I lied. But only about watching it.

I am still disappointed in it but not for the reasons you may think (unless of course you either 1. Know me or 2. Pay attention to me). So what’s my problem? I’ll be happy to tell you.

I can’t stand Kara DioGuardi. I don’t like her at all. It’s gotten to the point that I can’t even hear her voice without cringing. She brings NOTHING to the table in my opinion. She doesn’t even have original thoughts as far as I can see.

In general she is not the first judge to speak when it comes time for their thoughts on the performances. I think she must do that on purpose because when she does take her turn she basically repeats what the judge before her said. I hate that. If you have an opinion say it. Don’t just ‘go with the flow’. It doesn’t make you look good. At least not to me.

Plus she’s so concerned with telling people how good they look on stage. Huh? I thought this was a singing contest not a fashion show. Maybe I’m wrong. I understand that sadly your appearance does have a lot to do with your success in the music industry but I think at this point your voice should be more important. Several times Kara hasn’t said one thing about the contestant’s voice instead commenting on their outfit or their hair. I can think of several musicians that weren’t beauty queens or kings (Janis Joplin, Tom Petty, and Rick Ocasek just to name a few off the top of my head) but had incredible voices and were very successful because of those voices. That’s what music is about. The sound.

I was extremely pleased when on last nights show Paula Abdul pretty much shot Kara down in her tracks. Kara actually did comment first in that case and when she finished Paula said “I completely disagree” and then told WHY she disagreed. The crowd cheered; I laughed out loud. It was truly great! What makes that better for me personally is the fact that I normally don’t like Paula either. She earned a few points with me for that one.

I’ll leave you with a couple of videos I found on YouTube. I could talk all day about how much I hate Kara DioGuardi and how little talent I think she has (at least as a judge on American Idol. Honestly I don’t know about her other “talents” and I don’t want to know. She’s really on my nerves) and I think that would be boring so I’ll quit here.






6 COMMENTS:

Wendy said...

She doesn't bother me that bad, although I really don't like the 4-judge format. It's too long. After about the 2nd opinion we've heard all we need to hear and I'm nearly in a coma at that point. All I care about hearing is Randy and Simon anyway, although at least this year Paula is actually down on planet earth for a change.

However, what I *do* hate is the new format. YUCK! What is it with eliminating 9 people at a whack?? It's too traumatic for me. I'd like to get a chance to see them more than once. I don't like the new system AT ALL.

Deb said...

I do like Kara and I like Crazy Paula, but I don't like all the commercials every 2 minutes it seems, I realize you have to have them, but the 2 hour show could be done in less than an hour if they cut out some of the commercials. This is only the 2nd season I'm watching idol, but it is keeping me on pins and needles throwing so many out at one time, and are they all up for the 3 wildcard spots? I'm not really clear on that one.

hopefulcynic said...

I cannot stand Kara either. It's really useless to have her as I also noticed that she just repeats what the previous judge has said. Plus she rambles on and on where in tonight's show Simon said she was taking too long. Get rid of Kara. The show worked before without her, why mess with something that ain't broken?

Anonymous said...

Gawwwwd, i hate kara too, esp bcos of the "package artist" comment, the "frat boys" comment and so much more... HATE her...VFTW has many interesting takes on her, and i agree! She's so full of herself!

Jacob said...

I hate her as well! Hate hate hate!

Anonymous said...

I agree with the Kara haters. My favorite moment from last season was when Bikini Girl put Kara in her place. Who did Kara sleep with to get this gig? She's downright awful, and I wish she would shut up and go away. I like all of the other judges, though.

Post a Comment

If you can't fix it with duct tape, you haven't used enough.

You should really comment if you're here. It would make me very happy. I thrive on attention. You should know this by now. You should automatically click on the comment button and say SOMETHING! FEED MY NEED!! TALK TO ME!!!! Please. :)

Related Posts with Thumbnails